The gaming industry's shift towards live-service titles over the past decade has been a double-edged sword. While this model has led to the rise of enduring games like Fortnite and PUBG, many attempts by publishers to replicate that success have fallen short. Developing and Skull and Bones Items maintaining a thriving live-service experience requires a careful balance of engaging gameplay, meaningful progression systems, and a captivating ongoing narrative - challenges that Skull and Bones has struggled to overcome.

The game's lengthy and troubled development cycle, spanning nearly a decade with multiple restarts, has only compounded the obstacles it faces. When Skull and Bones finally launched in February 2023, it received a lukewarm critical reception, currently sitting at a 59 on Metacritic. Troubling player count reports further suggest the title may be adrift in the crowded live-service landscape.

According to a report from Insider Gaming, the game had only around 850,000 players across all platforms in its first week, a relatively low figure for a Ubisoft title, especially one touted as the company's first "AAAA" game. Complicating matters, this number included players using the game's free trial, meaning the actual paying playerbase was likely even smaller.

In contrast, the recent launch of Helldivers 2 – another live-service title – was met with much greater fanfare. Within its first few months, Helldivers 2 reported over 12 million sales, a figure Sony was eager to tout. Skull and Bones' silence on such metrics stands in stark comparison.

Transitioning to a free-to-play structure could be Skull and Bones' last chance to salvage its live-service ambitions. With full-price sales likely exhausted, making the game free to access may be the best path forward to sustain a playerbase and cheap Skull and Bones Items generate revenue through in-game purchases. It's a risky move, but one Ubisoft may ultimately need to consider if Skull and Bones is to avoid a watery grave.